Today’s guest Warrior Mom is Sierra R., who blogs at Everything Is Coming Up Roses. She’s sharing her frustration and disappointment with not having the natural childbirth she hoped for, and it’s contribution to her postpartum depression.
When I was pregnant, one of the most frequently asked questions I received was, “Do you have a birth plan?”
Normally, I have a plan for everything. I make lists for my lists and I love to be in control. And yet, ironically, I never really had a set birth plan. I was fine with having an epidural, being induced (if medically necessary) and I didn’t care if I had an IV. There was only one thing that I wanted, or rather, didn’t want: a c-section.
When I thought about my perfect labor, there was one image that stood out. I would visualize the moment immediately after my son was born. He would be placed on my chest, and I would look down at him in wonder and feel an overwhelming sense of love and peace. Then I would look into my husband’s eyes and we would smile at each other, softly crying tears of joy. We would snuggle together, just the three of us, as a new family.
I replayed this over and over in my head for months. It made me less afraid of my impending labor and even more excited to meet my baby, because I couldn’t wait for that moment to come true.
On the advice of our doctor, we decided to induce. I was five days late, my blood pressure had shot up, and I was showing signs of developing pre-eclampsia. The induction started out smoothly enough, thanks to our wonderful nurses and my husband. We hunkered down for a long night of waiting, but that’s not exactly what happened.
Every time I would stand up and sit back down, the baby’s heart rate would drop. My husband and I would hold our breath and listen to the heart rate monitor as it slowed from 130 down to 80, from 80 to 50, and on down. Our nurses kept telling me to flip over as they anxiously watched the monitor. I remember thinking, “What happens if his heart stops beating? How will they get him out in time?”
The tension in the tiny hospital room was palpable. I remember lying in the bed thinking, “What happens if he doesn’t make it?” After a few minutes, his heart rate came back up and we could all breathe again.
When my labor progress came to a halt, my OB broke my water and within an hour, I was ready to push. I pushed and I pushed, with all my might. The nurses tried to keep my spirits up by saying, “He’s right there! Keep pushing!” and I did. For two hours I pushed, but with every push, I knew.
Another memory, still clear as day: my OB leaving the foot of my bed, pulling down her mask, and walking to my side. She took my hand and gently said, “You’ve done a really great job, but your baby needs to come out now. I think you need to have a c-section”.
The rest is a blur: me sobbing hysterically, the nurses wheeling me into surgery, hearing my baby cry for the first time. He wasn’t placed on my chest; instead, a nurse held him next to my face so I could see him and then he was whisked away to the nursery.
My c-section had complications. I lost quite a bit of blood and came very close to needing a transfusion. When my husband came to see me in recovery he said my skin was green and I was shaking uncontrollably from the anesthesia. I didn’t get to touch my baby for more than three hours, and when I finally held him, I was in so much pain and so utterly exhausted I just wanted to hand him back to the nurse.
This is how I became a mother.
I struggled with feelings of disappointment, rage, guilt, failure and anger for months afterwards. I struggled with postpartum depression. One of my closest friends had a baby five months after I did, when my grief was still fresh in my mind. Her pregnancy had not been planned, but was welcomed just the same. She had an all-natural water birth, just as she had hoped for, and I remember sobbing at the perceived injustice of it all. Why did she get to have a natural birth? She wasn’t even sure if she wanted kids in the first place!
I would try to explain how I felt to my friends and other moms, but no one seemed to fully comprehend the depths of my grief. I got a lot of well intentioned, “You and your baby are healthy, that’s all that matters!” Saying this to a mom makes her feel that if she is upset over her birthing experience, she doesn’t appreciate the healthy baby she has. You are made to feel ashamed for grieving over your birth, like you’re ungrateful for the child you have. This couldn’t be farther from the truth.
It is okay to wish for something you didn’t have. This does not make you ungrateful for the healthy child that you have been blessed with. I love my son and I realize how lucky I am to have a healthy child. I know things could have been worse, much worse, but that doesn’t change the fact that there is a deep hole in my heart. A hole that may never completely heal.
I believe that is okay to grieve for your lost childbirth experience. In many ways, I actually think it is necessary to grieve. I lost something that meant so much to me, the dream of holding my newborn baby on my chest, the loving glances, the immediate bond you have with your child, and I will never get that back.
So allow yourself to shed some tears, even though your child is healthy, and to be angry that things didn’t turn out the way you had hoped. Only when you purge this grief, guilt, disappointment, and sadness, can you move forward and be the mother you were meant to be.
Photo credit: © jpcasais – Fotolia.com



Katherine Stone

Love to you, Sierra. I get it. With my whole heart, I get it. Thank you for sharing your story.
Thank you, so so much. Having followed your blog and reading about your struggles with a c-section & PPD, that truly means a lot. ♥
Wow thank you for sharing. What you just described is what I still suffer from silently for 2 years now. I had placental abruption and had an emerg c section and should be so blessed that I survived and my daughter survived as it was a near death experience for both of us. However I am still sad. The pain coupled with failing at breastfeeding are issues I still deal with. I was diagnosed with PPD right after my daughter’s birth and tried to deal with it the natural way….acupuncture, exercise, high doses of fish oil, relaxation techniques but the drugs were needed. Thanks again for sharing.
Oh Kim, I wish I could hug you right now. I’m sending you peace and love.
There are so many, too many, women who suffer in silence.
Thank you – this is something that every mom needs to hear! It is OK to grieve for the birth experience that you didn’t have.
Great post.
(((Sierra))) Thank you for sharing your struggle and strength with others
Sierra, thank you for opening up and sharing this. I know that (unfortunately) there are many, many women who can relate to these exact feelings.
You are a strong, beautiful momma.
Sierra,
That was so eloquently expressed, thank you for putting this out there. I to suffered from PPD greatly linked to not having the birth I planned as well as breast feeding issues. The best thing I was told was grieving what you loss is ok, and you can still celebrate the healthy baby as you said.
Thank you again for being brave and putting this out there!
(((Shawn))) I’m so glad that you were able to grieve your loss and move on to celebrate your beautiful, healthy baby.
Thank you for this strong, brave, eloquent post. Thank you for acknowledging that anger and sadness, and overwhelming joy and love can all be felt at the same time. Thank you for giving us permission to grieve unfulfilled expectations.
Thanks so sharing Sierra! My experience was similar, well said.
Yes, the only way to the other side is through. I too had to grieve for the birthing experience that I didn’t have. I have worked hard not to look back on the day my son was born with bitterness, but with joy. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for sharing your story!
Beautifully written and heart-wrenching. And the ability to grieve is so important.
Yes. This. Thank you so much for putting words to my thoughts.
Thank you so much for sharing Sierra. ♥ I can very much relate to this.
Thanks so much for sharing. I had a similar experience and can relate to your feelings. It’s so nice to hear about other moms who struggle with those feelings.
Sierra, thanks for sharing your story – and thank you for giving the rest of us the courage to face and grieve for what we’ve lost too. I’m a planner as well and went through a somewhat similar situation – it’s comforting to hear that these feelings of loss are common and that it’s ok to own up to them. Thank you!
Thanks so much for sharing your story, Sierra. I, too, had a very similar birth experience with a c-section and significant blood loss. Hearing someone validate the emotions I had about my birth experience means so much. Thank you, again, for writing this.
It’s been three years since my traumatic birth experience and this post brought tears to my eyes. I had a similar experience–induction for being overdue that ended up in a crash c-section. I will never forget it. My son is a blessing and a joy but his entry into the world has changed me forever. (((HUGS))) to all of you who had a similar experience.
Thank you so much for sharing, Sierra. I still have unresolved feelings about the way both of my birth experiences went. It’s always comforting and encouraging to hear that other people have similar feelings.
Thank you for sharing your story. I too had a difficult labor, and was separated from my son for almost 10 hours after he was born; I was too sick and exhausted to leave my bed, and he was in the NICU. And small wonder, I had little success breastfeeding, and ended up exclusively pumping for 8 months. I too know that things could have been so much worse, and I am so very lucky to have a healthy little boy, but I stewed over my experience, and felt haunted by it. It was only after I wrote down my birth story (in excruciating detail), and shared it with people I trusted, that I could start to let go of my anger, sadness, and disappointment. I wish you (and all who go through this) healing and peace!
Sierra, thank you so much for sharing this. While I am not a mom yet, this is one of my fears – that things won’t go as planned and I will be disappointed and feel like I should be happy anyway.
I also have a very close friend who had a horrible pregnancy – delivered at 26 weeks – and it is helpful to know a little more about how she probably feels.
Been there. I also had a hugely complicated birth that was drastically different from what I expected. (It involved preeclampsia too.) It is absolutely ok to grieve the experience. Mine was over 5 years ago – almost 6 and I’m not entirely over it. The ppd and ptsd symptoms are gone and I’ve channeled that energy into volunteer work, but it’s definitely always present in everything I do.
I had a very long drawn out labour with a large by in prosterior position. Like you, i was ok with the epidural and the 2 top ups they gave me. I spent over 2 hours with my legs in stirrups pushing. They let me tear to the point of needing well ovwr 17 internal and external stitches. I was exhausted from over 50hours i labour. My son struggled to latch to my breast so for 2 days i had him screaming from hunger. During this time I was develpoing a mass infection in my uterus from placenta that was left behind. I was on anti-depressants for the first 15mths of my sons life. I too, am angry and sad for missing out on that “wonderful” experience people told me I would have.
Thank you for putting into such beautiful words the feelings I had.
Beautiful. And so are you. Love you.
Sierra, this says it all so perfectly. My son was breech so I had a scheduled c-section. I didn’t have a single contraction and don’t know what labor is like at all. 4 years later people still say, “but he’s healthy and that’s all that matters.” and it’s not. Yes, it matters, but it’s not ALL that matters and we need to be able to grieve that. Good for you for letting yourself do that.
Thank you for writing this. I had a horrible birth (and I am a doula who planned a home birth) and struggled with postpartum depression. I lost enough blood for a transfusion and then my stitches developed granulation tissue that became infected so I was in a lot of pain for eight weeks or so after. I’m only just starting to see the light finally.
Thank you for sharing. I think it’s very important to admit you did want something a certain way, and to grieve that you lost that.
I can definitely relate to you. I pushed for 5 hours and at one point could even see her head in the mirror but she was stuck and I had to have a c-section. I too felt ripped off of the moment you see in the shows where they place the baby on your chest so you can hold it and stare at it. Instead your arms are stuck out at your side and you are so drugged up and tired you almost don’t even care. Honestly, as soon as I heard her cry I wanted to go to sleep. I know I felt like a failure for needing a c-section. I even asked my doc if I didn’t push good enough but her head really was stuck, she had fluid build up from rubbing on me to prove it. I knew I did the best I could but I still felt guilt. Plus, in our birth class a c-section was portrayed as a bad thing (we had a doula as the teacher which I’m sure may have been part of it). I am so jealous of moms who say they pushed twice and the baby was out. But yes, I can completely relate to what you said.
This hits very close to home.. I experienced almost the exact same thing! Thank you for this.
Wow, thanks for sharing your story! I completely understand how you feel. While this didn’t happen to me, I still was very adamant about the type of birth I wanted and could see how devastating it would be if it didn’t go as planned.
I think she is making too much of this! I lost two babies. Get over the little thing of having a c-section!
This may be your opinion but we should all be allowed to have our own feelings about our experiences. You don’t need to one up someone.
So powerful. Thank you for sharing this! I planned a homebirth and had a hospital cesarean. I was in labor for 3 days. I was crushed by my “inability” to “birth right” and it was the number 1 contributing factor to my PPD. In my PPD treatment group, 3 out of 7 women had unplanned cesareans after trying for a totally med-free birth, and they were all devastated.
I think we need to speak out about this issue more. Birth empowerment and choices are great. Yes, the c-section rate is shockingly high. But to combat this, I feel like we’ve put the onus all on women to be tougher, smarter, and to try harder for a very particular kind of birth. I read things when I was pregnant that told me that if I had a cesarean, my son and I wouldn’t bond, that he would be sickly, he wouldn’t nurse, and that I would just be one more awful statistic.
Despite following the advice of people like Ina May Gaskin to the LETTER, I still had a c-section. And I felt like a colossal failure. I wish our culture didn’t put such huge expectations on women to be perfect. Perfectly beautiful, perfectly rich, perfectly thin, and perfectly birthing.
I also wanted to share that I have a podcast called Broad Lives that collects women’s words and voices on issues of reproductive justice. Several of our episodes include moms who had unexpected birth experiences/feelings of deep disappointment. And they discuss how they felt it contributed to postpartum mood disturbances.
You can find us at broadlives.libsyn.com. The episodes that touch on this are:
Lexy
Cricket
Heather
Thank you so so so much to everyone for sharing your stories. It’s so important that we give voice to our grief, rather than bury it deep down for fear of being judged by others.
I with you all love, peace, and healing.
*wish
Thank you for sharing your story, Sierra! Your honesty is beautiful
Thank you for this story! I completely understand grieving an unnatural birth! I had a midwife through most of my pregnancy and had planned on a natural home birth. My baby ended up being born 5 weeks early by emergency c-section. Wish more people would understand that this is something acceptable to grieve over.
I love this site!! Just discovered it and plan to list it on my own private practice website. It’s chock full of great info and links. Kudos to Katherine Stone for this wonderful resource.
Elyse Everett, LCSW
ThePostpartumHighway.com